Theclaimers Logo

Is It Possible For Zelle to Steal From Your Bank Account?

These apps are more likely to be targeted by scammers and criminals for the same factors that drew users to them in the first place (free, quick, and easy). Banks assert that they are not required to reimburse clients who unintentionally permit fraudsters to use their accounts. Still, they are also hesitant to reimburse clients who have stolen money. It might be prohibited by law.
July 25, 2022
calculator with bank book

Millions of users have switched to using payment applications like Zelle, Venmo, and Cash App as their preferred method of money transfers in recent years. 

Banks are required by federal law to compensate clients for unlawful electronic transfers, but they frequently do not, leaving victims stranded. Banks contend that they shouldn’t be required to reimburse clients who unintentionally let a scammer use their accounts, and they have frequently been unwilling to reimburse clients whose money was stolen. That might be illegal in some circumstances. 

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau released rules last year stating that the bank was responsible for any unlawful online money transfers, defined as any payment initiated by someone other than the customer and completed without the customer’s permission. But despite the latest advice, banks frequently refuse to issue customer refunds. Argelis Oriech was robbed at gunpoint while on his way home from a shopping expedition one evening in March. He gave the robber his iPhone and the passcode. Mr. Oriac passed them over and took off.

The burglar had withdrawn $8,294 from Mr. Oriach’s Capital One bank accounts using several money transfer applications, including Zelle, according to Mr. Oriach, a Brooklyn resident. He got in touch with Capital One in the sincere hope that the company would follow federal law and give him back the money that had been taken. Only $250 was given back by the bank claimed to have uncovered no proof. Mr. Oriach narrated disbelief.

He said, “I filed a police report, identified the suspect on a campus, and even testified on a grand jury,” “But none of this seems to have helped my case.”


Would They Get Compensated?

Capital One officials responded to The New York Times’ inquiry regarding Mr. Oriach’s situation by stating that fraud had been discovered and that they would be compensated. Capital One sent a comment through email, saying, “We reached out to the customer to apologize for any additional stress this case may have caused,”

Millions of users have switched to using payment applications like Zelle, Venmo, and Cash App as their preferred method of sending money to another person in recent years. The nation’s most widely used payment app, Zelle, received $490 billion in payments last year, while Venmo, Zelle’s main competition, received $230 billion.

These apps are more likely to be targeted by scammers and criminals for the same factors that drew users to them in the first place (free, quick, and easy). Banks assert that they are not required to reimburse clients who unintentionally permit fraudsters to use their accounts. Still, they are also hesitant to reimburse clients who have stolen money.  It might be prohibited by law.

Suppose a client’s money is taken from a consumer account through an electronic payment triggered by another person, as in Mr. Oriach’s case. In that case, banks are compelled by a federal regulation from 1978 known as Regulation E to make the client whole.

Last year, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau released recommendations stating that Reg E covered all person-to-person internet payments because it was drafted before payment apps existed. The bureau made it clear that the bank was responsible for unapproved online money transfers, including any payments made without the customer’s knowledge and at the instigation of a third party.

If you have been scammed by an online scam then contact us to help you get your money back!


With how easy it is for scammers to acquire your data, it’s reasonable to be alarmed. Protect yourself and your loved ones by getting advice from experts. We will guide and even help you get your money back from scammers.

Inside Processes

According to Raul Cisneros, a spokesman for the bureau, “When a consumer provides notice to a financial institution that money was stolen from the consumer’s account, the burden is on the institution to show that the consumer authorized the transfer of funds out of the consumer’s account.” 

However, despite the updated advice, banks frequently refuse to reimburse clients who assert — frequently with supporting evidence — that money was stolen from their accounts. Customers who banks have wronged have few options because they rarely offer comprehensive justifications for their choices.

According to Chuck Roof, a burglar used the “SIM swapping” assault method to move his mobile phone number to another device in early February. The burglar then entered Mr. Roof’s Bank of America accounts using his number and withdrew $3,450 using Zelle. As soon as he learned of the theft, Mr. Roof reported it, but his claim was rejected. The transaction does not seem to be unauthorized, according to the bank.

In addition, Mr. Roof sent the bank a police report and a letter from Verizon outlining the events and pleading with it to review the case. They were instructed to hold off on responding for 45 days. He was instructed to wait till the allotted amount of time had elapsed. Mr. Roof talked on the phone for several hours, checking in on the status of his claim every few days.

“I said over and over, ‘I’ve never used Zelle. I’ve never authorized it,’” 34-year-old Bank of America client Mr. Roof declared, “I’ve never authorized it. I spoke once. Do you think I will go to the police department and file a false report? It is unlawful.

Bank of America gave Mr. Roof’s money back after being contacted by The Times. According to bank spokesman Bill Holdin, the bank has already started to second-guess its decision to pay the claim after evaluating new material presented by Mr. Roof.

It is difficult to determine the exact prevalence of frauds and thefts on Zelle because neither the bank nor Early Warning publicly provides any data on fraud. The occurrences mentioned by Mr. Oriach and Mr. Roof are “unusual” and make up a small amount of activity on the platform, according to Early Warning spokesperson Meghan Fintland.

Dr. Carla Licio of White Plains, New York, discovered $4,750 missing from her Chase checking account in January. She claimed to have notified the bank after finding out that the funds had been transferred via Zelle to an unfamiliar Gmail account. According to Ms. Licio, she did not transfer.

His attempts for compensation have been consistently denied by the bank, which has said that it has not discovered any evidence of fraud. The bank sent him a letter in March saying, “The device utilized is consistent with your history, no new devices were added, and there were no invalid login attempts.”

Ms. Licio expressed disbelief that her 25 years of flawless Chase customer service had been for nothing. Because they claim she is attempting to steal $4,750 from the bank, she stated, “They are labeling me a liar and a criminal.” “I truly want to tell them, but I’m at a loss for words. I can only say that I didn’t. And all you can say is that you don’t think I’m real.

Chase remained adamant about his choice when The Times approached him.

money lost online


Find Related News

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Scam Recovery Resources

Dating Scams & Romance Frauds Are Playing with People’s Feelings & Money

Online dating scams and romance frauds are not only manipulating the bank account of an innocent individual, but these scams are also playing with the heart and soul of people too! Romance scams occur when a criminal creates a fictitious online identity in order to gain the affection and trust of a victim. The scammer then creates the appearance of love or close relationship with the victim in order to deceive and/or steal from them. You may be surprised to learn that romance scams are one of the most common types of financial scams; in fact, research suggests that 1 in 7 dating profiles may be fake. 

Read More »

What Can Scammers Do with Your National Insurance Number & Personal Information?

This week, a number of police departments have tweeted alerts to the public in response to an increase in scammers posing as cops. Never give up your bank account information or National Insurance number over the phone to the police. The National Insurance scam follows a string of fraud attempts made on the populace while COVID-19 was in lockdown. A Royal Mail scam and a banking scam from the previous month are among these schemes.

Read More »

FundTrace is committed to upholding the journalistic standards online, including accuracy. With our news reporting, our policy is to review each issue on a case by case basis, immediately upon becoming aware of a potential error or need for clarification, and to resolve it as quickly as possible.

do you need help?

A lot of those who contact us have questions and concerns about their personal and business data being compromised. We aim to arm you with the legal and technical know-how in the fight against scams. Also, we will be able to refer you to top scam recovery agencies.

Please fill up the form. Rest assured that our support team will get in touch with you

Share this article
Leave a comment
Scan the code